MLB The Show 17 vs MLB The Show 23

Estimated sales, players and reviews of both games, side by side.

MLB The Show 17

SIE San Diego Studio · released March 28, 2017

PlayStation

Estimated sales

Not estimated

MLB The Show 23

SIE San Diego Studio · released March 28, 2023

XboxPlayStation

Estimated sales

90,000

all platforms · range 50K – 190K · as of Nov 16, 2026

Over time

Measure
Period
Scale
Latest readingMLB The Show 17no data for this periodMLB The Show 231,719

MLB The Show 23: tracked since September 2026, so its line starts 3 years and 5 months after launch. Nothing is known before that.

Number of ratings left on the PlayStation Store (PS4 and PS5). It is not a player count, but it follows activity on PlayStation. Xbox ratings have been tracked for too short a time to draw a line.

Comparison table

Today's figures. MLB The Show 17 came out 9 years and 7 months ago, MLB The Show 23 3 years and 7 months ago: running totals favour MLB The Show 17.

Measure
MLB The Show 17
MLB The Show 23
Gap
Consolesnumber of store ratings, not players

PlayStation Store ratings

n/a

1,719

★ 4.06 / 5

—

Xbox Store ratings

not on this platform

548

★ 2.4 / 5

—
Details

Current price

—

$29.99

—

Age

since launch

9 years and 7 months

3 years and 7 months

—

Release

March 28, 2017

March 28, 2023

—

Studio

SIE San Diego Studio

SIE San Diego Studio

—

Publisher

Sony Interactive Entertainment

Sony Interactive Entertainment

—

Other comparisons